Ethel Cain - Willoughby Tucker, I'll Always Love You (2025) Review

Updated: Oct 28
“Willoughby Tucker, I’ll Always Love You” is Ethel Cain’s best album.
I will admit, there is nothing like listening to “Preacher’s Daughter” for the first time. In the long term though, I keep coming back to “Willoughby Tucker” instead. There’s a reason why Hayden Anhedönia, the one behind the Ethel Cain persona, couldn’t move on from the idea of Willoughby Tucker as a character after she released “Preacher’s Daughter.”
“Willoughby Tucker” is a prequel to the story told in “Preacher’s Daughter.” The album is a story of young love and loss, as it follows Ethel as a teenager falling in love with Willoughby, doubting their relationship, and grieving when he’s gone.
Although one could argue “Preacher’s Daughter” is more emotionally impactful, I disagree. This album just goes about making that impact in a different way. The songs in “Willoughby Tucker” don’t have the same big moments as songs like “Ptolemaea,” but they don’t need those moments to make you feel something. Lyrically, Anhedönia uses a lot of repetition to emphasize Ethel’s pain. Almost every song on the album has repeating lyrics, whether it’s “to love me is to suffer me” in “Nettles,” or simply repeating the word “forever” in the outro of “Tempest.” She also gives space to the lyrics though, letting the instrumentals convey those feelings, and allowing the listener to sit with her words.
Musically, this album feels like Anhedönia is really settling into a signature sound. This album is much more ambient than most of her previous work, something she started to establish in the album she released before this one. This style suits her so well. The transition from “Radio Tower” to “Tempest” is practically unnoticeable. The whole album flows so well together. Three out of the ten songs on the tracklist are instrumentals, and even without lyrics, these songs still evoke the melancholy that is present throughout the whole album.
Nettles, which is track 4 on the album, is my personal favorite song of hers, and potentially the best one she’s ever written. The song tells a story Ethel imagines, where Willoughby is dying in the hospital. Even though it’s a completely imaginary scenario, she mourns him and reminisces on the love that they had. Both the lyrics and the music perfectly portray the grief of losing someone, but also being grateful for everything they gave you before they left. She’s writing a song about a character that’s not actually going through anything described in the song, and the fact that she’s able to put so much emotion into a song that’s so removed from the actual experience is insane.
This album is such a beautiful work of art. It’s clear to me how Ethel Cain’s previous works have led up to this point in her artistic career. From continuing the storyline started in “Preacher’s Daughter,” to keeping with the ambient sound she discovered on “Perverts,” this album is a culmination of everything she’s created so far. I’m so excited to see how she builds on her career.




Comments